Highlights

  • Union Law Minister says Indians unhappy with collegium system
  • He opined that it is the government's job to appoint judges
  • Supreme Court collegium headed by CJI, comprises of 4 other judges

Latest news

Dominique Pelicot sentenced to 20 years in landmark French mass rape case

Dominique Pelicot sentenced to 20 years in landmark French mass rape case

PM Modi speaks to King Charles, reaffirms India-UK strategic partnership

PM Modi speaks to King Charles, reaffirms India-UK strategic partnership

Omar Abdullah meets Amit Shah, discusses J&K's statehood restoration

Omar Abdullah meets Amit Shah, discusses J&K's statehood restoration

Unprecedented fracas on Parliament premises, 2 BJP MPs injured; NDA, Congress file police complaints

Unprecedented fracas on Parliament premises, 2 BJP MPs injured; NDA, Congress file police complaints

Palestinians say six killed in Israeli West Bank operations

Palestinians say six killed in Israeli West Bank operations

Around 70 Hindu pilgrims arrive in Pak from India to perform religious rituals at Katas Raj temples

Around 70 Hindu pilgrims arrive in Pak from India to perform religious rituals at Katas Raj temples

Delhi Elections: MCD passes proposal to release Rs 25.35 crore for preparations

Delhi Elections: MCD passes proposal to release Rs 25.35 crore for preparations

Global stocks struggle amid inflation, economic fears: December 19, 2024 analysis

Global stocks struggle amid inflation, economic fears: December 19, 2024 analysis

It is govt's job to appoint judges: Law Minister Rijiju on collegium system

The minister's remarks came after he had said at a conference in Jaipur last month that there is a need to rethink the collegium system of appointments to the higher judiciary.

It is govt's job to appoint judges: Law Minister Rijiju on collegium system

Union Law and Justice Minister Kiren Rijiju said the people of the country are not happy with the collegium system and according to the spirit of the Constitution, it is the government's job to appoint judges.

Speaking at 'Sabarmati Samvad' organised here on Monday by 'Panchjanya', a weekly magazine published by the RSS, he said he has observed that half of the time judges are "preoccupied" with deciding the appointments, due to which their primary job of delivering justice "suffers".

The minister's remarks came after he had said at a conference in Jaipur last month that there is a need to rethink the collegium system of appointments to the higher judiciary.

"Till 1993, every judge in India was appointed by the law ministry in consultation with the Chief Justice of India. We had very eminent judges at that time," Rijiju said in response to a question on the process of appointment of judges.

"The Constitution is clear about it. It says that the President of India will appoint judges, that means the law ministry will appoint judges in consultation with the Chief Justice of India," he said.

"The Supreme Court in 1993 defined consultation as concurrence. In no other field has consultation been defined as concurrence but in judicial appointments," he said, adding that the collegium system was expanded by the judiciary in 1998.

The Supreme Court collegium is headed by the Chief Justice of India and comprises four seniormost judges of the court.

Also Watch| Historic first: Supreme Court begins live streaming of constitutional bench

While the government can raise objections or seek clarifications regarding the collegium's recommendations, it is bound by procedure to clear the names if the five-member body reiterates them.

"I am aware that the people of the country are not happy with the collegium system of appointment of judges. If we go by the spirit of the Constitution, appointing judges is the job of the government," said.

"Second thing, nowhere in the world except India is there a practice that judges appoint their brothers as judges.

"Third, as the law minister, I have observed that half of the time and minds of judges are preoccupied with deciding who will be the next judge. Their primary work is to give justice, which suffers due to this practice," he said.

"Further, the process of consultation for the selection of judges is so intense that, I am sorry to say such a thing, groupism develops in it. People can see politics among leaders but they do not know the politics going on inside the judiciary," he added.

Rijiju said the law ministry's job is to see that the person whose name has been recommended for appointment by the collegium is fit to be a Supreme Court or high court judge.

"A judge will be above criticism if he is not involved in the selection of another judge. But if he is involved in the administrative work, then he or she is not above criticism," he said.

In 2014, the NDA government had tried to change the system of appointing judges.

The National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC) Act brought in 2014 would have accorded a major role to the executive in appointing judges to the higher judiciary. However, it was struck down by the Supreme Court in 2015.

Responding to a question on judicial activism, Rijiju said, "Several judges pass observations which never become part of the judgement. During my consultations with them, I have requested them to refrain from it, especially when live streaming of court proceedings is taking place. They are being judged by the people." "As a judge, you might not know the practical difficulties or even financial implications of the order you pass," he said.

"We have three pillars — the executive, legislature and judiciary. The executive and the legislature are bound and regulated by the judiciary. But if the judiciary goes astray, there is no mechanism to control it," he said.

ADVERTISEMENT

Up Next

It is govt's job to appoint judges: Law Minister Rijiju on collegium system

It is govt's job to appoint judges: Law Minister Rijiju on collegium system

Omar Abdullah meets Amit Shah, discusses J&K's statehood restoration

Omar Abdullah meets Amit Shah, discusses J&K's statehood restoration

Unprecedented fracas on Parliament premises, 2 BJP MPs injured; NDA, Congress file police complaints

Unprecedented fracas on Parliament premises, 2 BJP MPs injured; NDA, Congress file police complaints

Around 70 Hindu pilgrims arrive in Pak from India to perform religious rituals at Katas Raj temples

Around 70 Hindu pilgrims arrive in Pak from India to perform religious rituals at Katas Raj temples

Delhi Elections: MCD passes proposal to release Rs 25.35 crore for preparations

Delhi Elections: MCD passes proposal to release Rs 25.35 crore for preparations

Union Home Minister Amit Shah reviews J&K security situation

Union Home Minister Amit Shah reviews J&K security situation

ADVERTISEMENT

editorji-whatsApp

More videos

BJP MPs admitted in RML Hospital ICU with head injuries after scuffle with opposition

BJP MPs admitted in RML Hospital ICU with head injuries after scuffle with opposition

Parliament Protest Melee: Congress claims Kharge pushed, Rahul manhandled

Parliament Protest Melee: Congress claims Kharge pushed, Rahul manhandled

Mumbai boat tragedy: Ferry ‘Neel Kamal’ was packed beyond capacity, say police

Mumbai boat tragedy: Ferry ‘Neel Kamal’ was packed beyond capacity, say police

Indian Educationist Arun Kapur honoured with Bhutan’s prestigious royal honour ‘Dasho’

Indian Educationist Arun Kapur honoured with Bhutan’s prestigious royal honour ‘Dasho’

Uttar Pradesh: Six killed in Shahjahanpur road accident

Uttar Pradesh: Six killed in Shahjahanpur road accident

Arvind Kejriwal urges NDA allies to reconsider support for BJP over Amit Shah’s Ambedkar remark

Arvind Kejriwal urges NDA allies to reconsider support for BJP over Amit Shah’s Ambedkar remark

Andhra High Court upholds lesbian couple’s right to live together, parents told not to ‘interfere’

Andhra High Court upholds lesbian couple’s right to live together, parents told not to ‘interfere’

FIR against Samajwadi Party’s Sambhal MP for power theft

FIR against Samajwadi Party’s Sambhal MP for power theft

Mumbai boat tragedy: Life jackets made mandatory for rides from Gateway of India

Mumbai boat tragedy: Life jackets made mandatory for rides from Gateway of India

Eknath Shinde pays tribute to RSS founder, highlights Sangh's nation-building role

Eknath Shinde pays tribute to RSS founder, highlights Sangh's nation-building role

Editorji Technologies Pvt. Ltd. © 2022 All Rights Reserved.